limegreensquid (limegreensquid) wrote in atuan,
limegreensquid
limegreensquid
atuan

Alder is Very Similar to George

I'm reading "The Lathe of Heaven" by Ursula K. LeGuin, and the character George is VERY much like Alder of "The Other Wind". Both have dreams that can affect real life in tremendous, and epic ways. Although it is described in The Other Wind that Alder's dreams were more of the message of the world changing being sent through him, whereas George's dreams actually change the reality of the world for everyone, making those people think what he had dreamed had always been the way of life.
But their personalities are so similar - they feel like they are small people, not really worthy of messing with the high powers of the universe.

George is trying not to have dreams because they might end up changing the world, and he doesn't believe he should have the right to change things as they are.
Alder is trying not to have dreams so that he isn't pulled over the low stone wall in the Dry Land and let all the dead that cry out to him loose, or pull him over the wall with them.

Both of them don't believe they are "big" enough people in their worlds to be meddling with such world-altering affairs.

Both of them are very quiet, almost shy men, very humble and heartfully honest. To use this character twice in her books, i wonder who she is refering to ... or if she is refering to herself? Has it ever been known whether she has had dreams that she wished not to have? So much that she had tried to escape them by any method available to her?

George with his illegal use of the drug-cards, Alder with little Tug, the kitten. And then if you remember Ged as well was pulled back into his body by the touch of the little Otak, but that wasn't really sleep ... just a parallel reference.

And in one of George's dreams he sees an Alder tree. A little bit of a stretch, but you never know ... maybe she wanted a 'George' in "The Other Wind" and came across the word 'Alder' when she was re-reading through "The Lathe of Heaven" and came across the word, as i did, and thought, "That'd be a perfect name!"
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments
That is an excellent comparison! And I just finished a re-read of The Other Wind so maaaaaann, you've totally got me wanting to do a re-read of Lathe.

See, this is why I love being a reader and a writer, in the hope of reading posts exactly like this.
Hehe, awesome! Yah, when i can really get into a book i like discussing it, but there are usually so few responses, so thanks! I'm glad i could inspire someone to go back into another of her books, hehe!
You know how hard it is to try and find a Lord of the Rings community here that has been active within the last year at all? I've tried to ask and discuss things but i get no answer. I guess the real fans were scared away by the movie-walkers-by, and now that the movies are more than a year or 2 old, the movie-fans got bored with them, and left the communities as empty husks.